This article is published in AL-QALAM Journal of Languages and Literary Studies, Vol. 1, Issue 1, December 2025 (A Publication of the Department of English and Literature, Federal University Gusau, Zamfara State, Nigeria)
REWRITING
APPRAISAL: A DISCOURSE ANALYSIS OF MENTAL HEALTH RECOVERY NARRATIVE
By
Ogunjimi, Florence Taiye
Department of Languages and Linguistics Gombe State University,
Gombe, Nigeria
&
Adam Al. Amin Abdullahi
(PhD)
Department of English and Literary Studies, Federal University of
Lafia, Nasarawa State, Nigeria
&
Blossom Shimayam Ottoh-Agede (PhD)2
Department of English and Literary Studies, Federal University of
Lafia, Nasarawa State, Nigeria
Corresponding
Author’s email & Phone No: taiwoflo.tf@gsu.edu.ng +2348036042868
Abstract
Several
studies show how computational linguistics has identified broad lexical markers
of mental distress. However, a gap exist in understanding how people affected
by mental health conditions linguistically evaluate and construct their
subjective experiences. This study addresses this gap using a detailed
Appraisal analysis (Martin & White, 2005) of a single, Nigerian podcast
narrative on depression and anxiety. Moving beyond thematic description, this
study analyses how the narrator uses the Attitude system of Attitude,
Engagement, and Graduation to build their reality. The study argues that
Appraisal Theory provides an imperative framework for capturing the functional
relationship of language and emotion in mental health narratives. The findings
have implications for discourse analysis, culturally-grounded mental health
communication, and therapeutic practices. That is, the research foregrounds
that healing is, in part, a linguistic act of learning to re-appraise one’s own
story. The research reveals that the narrator’s depressive state is devised
through the expressions of negative attitudinal judgment, condensed engagement,
and intensified graduation. Essentially, the study establishes that the path to
recovery is linguistically recorded not by the absence of this negative
discourse, but by the strategic change of appraisal constructions.
Keywords:
Appraisal, Mental health, Depression, Anxiety, Discourse analysis
1.0
Introduction
Mental
health is a complex component of the overall well-being of man. The
understanding of this concept has been a subject of ongoing debate.
Traditionally, mental health has been viewed through the restricted standpoint
of clinical knowledge (O'Reilly & Lester, 2017). That is, clinically, it is
seen as the absence of mental illness that shies away from other factors.
However, contemporary understanding of mental health issues has evolved towards
a more and all-inclusive approach. Defining mental health, the World Health
Organisation (2022) describes it as "a state of mental well-being that
enables people to cope with the stresses of life, realise their abilities,
learn well and work well, and contribute to their community." This
definition stresses a positive state of functioning that encompasses emotional
resilience, psychological well-being, and the ability for social contribution.
Nonetheless, this ideal of mental state is tricky for a significant portion of
people with conditions like depression and anxiety which represents the leading
cause of disability worldwide (WHO, 2016).
In Nigeria,
mental health challenge is severe. This is because, issues around mental health
are compounded by widespread stigma, scarce human resources, and treatment
inadequacy that leaves majority of affected people without care (Saied, 2023).
Therefore, the Nigerian situation, with its distinctive socio-cultural
pressures and a struggling healthcare system, makes the need to understand
mental health challenges essential. Despite these burden, mental health
intervention in Nigeria has always been shaped specifically by clinical,
psychological, and medical approaches (Fadele et al. 2023). While this is
important, these models tend to overlook the dimensions in which individuals
themselves linguistically construct and communicate their lived experiences outside
clinical settings.
The rise of
digital platforms (Turn table charts, 2023) has begun to democratise this
discourse. Digital platforms now create new, accessible playgrounds for
personal narrative and testimony that evade traditional gatekeeper. Chief among
these digital platforms is the podcast. The podcast is a streaming audio and
video platform for online streaming of contents. It has also proven to be a
transformative force discussion related to health matters (Viavonu 2025,
February 19). As a streaming platform, podcast about mental health issues often
provide a personal and unedited ground for people who suffer one form of mental
health condition or the other. It enables them to share detailed stories of
their emotional struggles, coping mechanisms, and recovery journeys (Sakai
& Lam, 2025; Bharat, 2023; Owolabi et al., 2024). Consequently, these
narratives provides rich, naturalistic vault of data for understanding mental
health conditions from the standpoint of those who live or have lived with it.
Although quite
a number of researches have started analysing mental health discourse online, a
significant linguistic gap still remains. For example, some studies have
consistently relied on computational methods to identify key words or broad
linguistic categories. They include the elevated use of first-person singular
pronouns and negative emotional words in online forums (Lyons et al., 2018).
Other studies also focus on classifying texts diagnostic purposes using machine
learning. However, these approaches, while they are very useful, do not usually
provide deep, qualitative explanation of how language is used to achieve
evaluate stance and assign personal meaning to the experience of mental health
challenges. The important question is not merely what is said, but how
it is said. How do narrators linguistically appraise their emotions, judge
their own actions, and evaluate the very nature of their condition.
This
study is about addressing this how. To achieve this, it requires a
detailed linguistic framework that is capable of capturing the exquisiteness of
evaluation and stance. In this wise, this study employ Appraisal Theory
propounded by Martin and White, (2005). The appraisal theory is an extended
interpersonal approach within the Systemic Functional Linguistics. This model
provides a systematic taxonomy for analysing the language of evaluation. These
taxonomies are attitude, engagement and graduation. They are employed to
analyse a Nigerian podcast narrative on depression and anxiety.
1.1 Research
Objective
This
study is guided by the following research question: What patterns of evaluative
language are evident in the target Nigerian mental health podcast narrative,
and how do these patterns, analysed through appraisal model, convey narrator’s
the attitude toward their experiences? By answering this question, this study
aims to contribute to a detailed linguistically grounded understanding of
mental health discourse in a non-clinical, Nigerian context. The study is a
demonstration of the efficacy of appraisal theory to move beyond content
analysis and reveal the complex interpersonal work accomplished through
language.
2.0 Literature
Review and Theoretical Framework
This
section reviews the concept of mental health and its conditions, empirical
studies on language and mental health. It also identifies a key gap that this
study hopes to fill. It then introduces Appraisal Theory as the framework
designed to fill the gap in the research.
2.1 Mental
Health
Across
the world, mental health has been acknowledged as a fundamental part of man’s
overall health. According to the World Health Organisation (2022), mental
health encompasses physical, mental, and social well-being. It is the state
that enables people cope with the normal stresses of life. In their report about what should constitute
mental health, the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation, (2024) observes
that, achieving a consensus on the precise meaning of what constitutes mental
health is challenging. This according to the institute may be due to
significant conceptual variations across disciplines and cultures (Lee, et al.,
2023).
Nonetheless,
some definitions have shown to reflect a shift from clinical focus on pathology
toward a more comprehensive framework of wellbeing. Chief amongst these, is the
American Psychological Association (2013). In its definition, it declares
mental health as ‘a state of mind that is characterised by emotional wellbeing,
good behavioral adjustment, complete freedom from anxiety. Individuals must
also have the capacity to establish meaningful relationships and cope with the
ordinary demands and stresses of life.’ This view, which emphasises positive
functioning and resilience, arguably agrees with more recent modern ideologies
like the World Health Organisation's (2025) definition of mental well-being.
In Nigeria,
however, the ideal understanding of mental well-being is far from what is
obtained in reality. Historically, the Nigerian government's engagement with
mental health has always been characterised by neglect and legislative inaction
(Ogunwale, Ogunlesi, Shepherd, Serpa, & Singh, 2021). Substantiating this
fact, the Federal Republic of Nigeria (2021) Act, asserts that for decades, the
principal legislation for mental health was the Lunacy Act of 1958. In fact,
(Ugwu & Baiye, 2022) mention that it was a colonial-era law that found its
way to post independence Nigeria. This law uses negative labelling terminology
on people with mental illness rather than make provision for treatment and
human rights privileges. This created a significant policy vacuum that
persisted long after global understandings of mental health had evolved.
Making headway,
a landmark development took place with the passage of the National Mental
Health Act in 2021. It was later signed into law in January 2023. This Act
among other things, seeks to reconcile Nigeria's mental health framework with
international human rights standards. This way, its primary concern was to
promote access to care and protect the rights of persons with mental health
challenges.
2.2 Mental
Health Conditions
Studies
have shown that mental health conditions are a growing concern worldwide (Kola,
2020; World Health Organization, 2021; Rahman et al., 2021) According to the
American Psychiatric Association (2013), different kinds of mental health
conditions affect millions of people from all walks of life. These conditions
cover a broad range, including bipolar disorder, substance abuse disorder,
anxiety, depressive disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), psychosis,
and others. By definition, mental health condition is a generic term for a
category of ‘illness’ that may input on a person’s emotional state such as
thoughts, perception, feelings and behaviors. These states can impact a
person’s day-to-day living and may also affect their ability to relate with
others (National Alliance on Mental Illness, 2024).
Without doubt,
findings have shown that mental health conditions have proven to be far more
common than many physical health conditions (Samsudin, Ismail, Said, &
Yahya, 2024). However, this fact is often concealed from the public’s
consciousness. This may be attributed to the prevalent stigma that surrounds
mental health issues. In other words, unlike physical health issues, mental
health conditions are less discussed in the open. This has created a lack of
understanding and awareness about their prevalence. Accordingly, the UNC Health
Caldwell (2022), reports that many people remain ignorant that mental health
conditions significantly affect a large proportion of the world’s population
silently and gradually.
2.3 Spectrum of
Mental Health Conditions
The
American Psychiatric Association, states that mental health conditions can be
categorised into several types (2013). Although different schools of thought
may differ slightly in their classification systems (Kas et al. 2025;
Wijtenburg et al. 2025; World Health Organization 2024), research identify
similar types of mental health conditions. Some of these conditions are: eating
disorder, bipolar disorder, depression, anxiety disorder, substance abuse
disorder, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), attention deficit
hyperactivity disorder, psychosis among others. However, this research pays
particular focus on depression and anxiety disorders, which are the primary
concern of this research. This is due to their high prevalence and profound
impact on individuals and the society at large.
2.3.1
Depression and Anxiety
Depression
and anxiety are two of the most pervasive and psychologically impairing mental
health conditions that are marked by sustained emotional, cognitive, and
behavioural disturbances (WHO, 2021). Mental health conditions such as anxiety
and depression are highly prevalent in all countries and communities, affecting
people of all ages and income levels. They represent the second biggest reason
for long-term disability, contributing to loss of healthy lifestyle. They drive
up health-care costs for affected people and families while inflicting
substantial economic losses on a global scale (WHO, 2025). Defining depression,
Adeleke et al., (2025) describe it as a condition that is typically
characterised by persistent feelings of worthlessness, and a loss of interest
in previously pleasurable activities. While, anxiety disorder on the other
hand, mostly manifests through persistent physiological stimulation and
expectant fear (Spytska, 2024).
In its report,
the National Alliance on Mental Illness (2024), documented that around the
world, over 280 million people suffer from depression, and more than 300
million people live with anxiety disorders. These figures therefore, positioned
these conditions as one the leading contributors to disability and suicide
worldwide. Authenticating this claim, Alpium and Ehrenberg (2023), are of the
opinion that these conditions influence more than just a person's internal pain
or cause disability. According to them, these conditions also reshape the
patients' reality about life; a process this current study agrees is revealed
through the language employed to express distresses.
In
Sub-Saharan Africa, researches have emphasise the significant burden of
depression and anxiety on humans and on the society (Haruna, Muhammad, &
Braimon 2025). For example, they noted that a systematic review of depression
reveals that major depressive disorder (MDD) is a leading cause of disability
and psychosocial impairment in this region. The World Health Organisation also
predicted that by 2030 it is most likely to become one of the foremost
contributors to global mental illness (National Alliance for Mental Illness,
2024). In Nigeria however, depression and anxiety are further complicated by
socio-cultural and structural factors such as stigma, spiritual inclinations
and inadequate access to orthodox care (Jidong, Husain, Francis, et al., 2021).
Also, according to national data, Nigeria shows a 3.1% lifetime prevalence for
major depressive episodes and 5.7% for anxiety disorders. These figures
however, are likely to underrepresent the true nature of the problem due to
certain cultural beliefs that discourage open emotional expression (Ibigbami et
al., 2022).
More studies
within Nigeria further illustrate these trends. For instance, Abubakar and
Abubakar (2024) conducted a descriptive cross-sectional study in Kano state
among adult outpatients at Akilu Memorial Comprehensive Hospital and Murtala
Muhammad Specialists’ Hospitals respectively. The findings of their research
reveals extremely high prevalence rates of depression amongst patients, at 70%
and 90%, respectively. Their research reveal further, the prevalent yet often
unrecognised nature of depressive symptoms in clinical populations. Put simply,
their study warns that without paying attention to factors like psychological
cues, behavioural signals and language use; symptoms of depressive and anxiety
disorder may remain hidden.
Based on
available literatures, it is worthy to note that these conditions are not just
clinical conditions but discursive phenomena that are shaped by language use.
Reason being that, mental distress is mostly expressed through language
structures such as “I think too much” that signal psychological suffering but
often elude clinical recognition.
2.4 The Shift From Clinical Diagnosis to Public Discourse
From the above
discussions, it is not new that mental health discourse has witnessed scholarly
transformation. It has migrated from the restricted authoritative spaces of the
clinic to a more dynamic, multi-vocal arena of public life (Banjo, Eruchie, &
Agbo, 2025). This is more than just a change of setting; it is a fundamental
re-negotiation of who gets to define, describe, and deliberate on experiences
of psychological distress.
Traditionally,
mental health which was the exclusive business of clinical medicine was framed
by specialised diagnostic manuals like the DMS. Their ideologies were
communicated through specialised language of healthcare professionals (NIMH,
2025). This model, even though it has proven to be very significant for
standardised diagnosis and treatment, it has been critiqued for its
oversimplification of experiences. The clinical perspective mostly views
distress entirely as a biomedical term. This approach often marginalise a
patient's lived experience and overlook other social determinants of health.
Corroborating this point, Hari in his book Lost
Connections (2018), posits that the fundamental limitation of biomedical
models lies in its approach of marginalising the patient's lived experience and
overlooking critical social determinants of health. Hari persuasively reframes
depression and anxiety not as chemical malfunctions but as understandable
responses to societal "disconnections". This could be any kind of
disconnections ranging from meaningful work, supportive community, family ties
and even a secure future among others.
Although
Hadi's perspective on mental health issues has been challenged for
oversimplifying neurobiological complexity, its strength lies in the validation
of personal narratives and contextualising distress within social and economic
realities. This argument resonates strongly with the current research. This is
because, the narrator consistently expresses their emotional struggles not by
the way of clinical terminology but using the language of socioeconomic
pressure, cultural disintegration, dysfunctional relationships among others.
This approach helps patients to reclaim their stories from reductive pathology
and grounding them in lived reality.
2.5 Appraisal
and the Language of Intersubjective Stance
The
Appraisal model, that was advanced by the work of White (2014), provides a
significant standpoint for understanding how language evaluates and constructs
interpersonal relationships in discourse. The model moves beyond traditional
concepts like modality and hedging, to providing a detailed discourse-semantic
account of how speakers and writers encode their opinions, judgments, and
emotions. This framework is fundamentally dialogic in nature. That is, its
ideology was inspired by Bakhtin's view that all communication exists in a
landscape of alternative voices and societal positions. His work looks at how a
textual voice positions itself in relation to these other viewpoints, making
the expression of attitude not merely a personal comment but an act of negotiating
solidarity with the audience.
Martin and
White (2005), systematically organise the framework of appraisal into three
related domains. Attitude is concerned with feelings, covering emotions
(Affect), ethical assessments of behavior (Judgment), and evaluations of
phenomena (Appreciation). Engagement however,
deals with the sourcing of attitudes and the management of the dialogic space.
It analyses whether a discourse acknowledges other viewpoints (Heteroglossia)
or presents itself as a single, authoritative voice (Monoglossia). Lastly, Graduation
provides the tools for scaling the intensity of these evaluations, either in
terms of force (amplifying or diminishing) or focus (sharpening or softening
categorical boundaries).
This detailed
framework has over the years been extensively applied across different
contexts. This include and not limited to political discourse (Dajur, 2023)
media discourse (Adebayo, 2024) to educational linguistics (Hood, 2010).
However, its application to a real-life narrative of mental health recovery,
specifically within the Nigerian socio-cultural context, is under explored.
This gap is significant, because personal narratives are fertile grounds for
examining how individuals discursively negotiate profound personal
transformation. Therefore, this study adopts the Appraisal framework to
investigate the linguistic construction of depression and anxiety and how
resilience is achieved. It posits that the model’s systems for tracking
evaluative language are ideally suited to trace the discursive trajectory from
a depressive self. A self that is characterised by negative appraisal and
dialogic contraction, to a resilient self, marked by a strategic re-evaluation
of attitude, engagement, and graduation. This research aims to contribute to
the field by demonstrating the framework's usage in modeling the linguistic
mechanics of recovery.
3.0 Methodology
This
study is a qualitative case study design. It utilises a discourse analysis of a
single, podcast narrative to provide a detailed understanding of how evaluative
language constructs the experience of mental illness. The analysis is logically
guided by the three subsystems (attitude, engagement and graduation) of
appraisal theory propounded by Martin & White (2005). The analysis is
presented in a structured table format, detailing the linguistic realisations
of these appraisal subsystems in key excerpts. It is followed by a synthesis
that traces the evolving patterns across the narrative arc. This approach is
suited to dissect the linguistic encoding of emotions, ethical judgments,
dialogic positioning, and possible rhetorical force in the analysed narrative.
This approach although focuses on analytical depth also allow for the
examination of the relationship between language and subjective experience
within a real-world context.
The data for
this analysis is a precisely transcription of a single podcast episode. It is
sourced from a Nigerian mental health podcast named: “Let’s talk Mental Health”
from Spotify (a streaming online service). Hosted by Jyde Onakan, @WithJyde.
The episode titled, “Looking for validation, my journey through depression and
anxiety” is consciously chosen for its explicit and detailed first-person
narrative mode by a Nigerian survivor of depression and anxiety. The episode is
also transcribed with careful attention to paralinguistic features (e.g.,
emphatic stress, pauses) to capture the full detail of appraising although not
the focus for analysis. The analysis proceeded through a systematic coding
process, where the transcript is repeatedly analysed and coded for instances
across the three appraisal domains. These processes enable the identification
of dominant patterns in the narrative. Also, it aids in the identification of
strategic uses of evaluative language to construct the narrator's specific interpersonal
stance and trace their rhetorical trajectory. Lastly, ethical thoroughness is
maintained by using only publicly accessible data and anonymising the
narrator's identity in the presentation of findings.
4.0 Analysis
and Findings:
This
section provides a comprehensive discourse analysis of the data. The analysis
moves beyond broad categories to examine the specific lexical, syntactic, and
discursive choices as employed by the narrator. Other choices that help the
narrator construct experience of depression and anxiety via traumatic events
and resilience through the Appraisal frame are also identified and analysed.
The following tables detail the linguistic resources used in each narrative
excerpt. It provides the evidence base for tracing the narrator's journey from
a state of being appraised by depressive states to becoming the agent of their
own positive appraisal.
|
Excerpt &
Selected expressions |
ATTITUDE |
ENGAGEMENT |
GRADUATION |
|
Except 1 |
Judgment Words like
'violent home,' 'insults' were employed to explicitly judge the narrator’s
parents' behavior. |
Monoglossia: The phrase
'I was raised...' presents childhood trauma as uncontestable by the narrator. Heteroglossia (Expand: Entertain):
'Imagine... asking neighbors… for money' is used to builds empathy. |
Force The
metaphorical verb 'raining insults' is employed by the narrator to amplify the extent of abuse suffered by the narrator; ‘it wasn’t funny at all' intensifies the
gravity of their experience. |
|
Excerpt 2 |
Judgment When the
speaker concludes that they are ‘unworthy of love’; the phrase actually
internalises the neglect experienced by the narrator. |
Heteroglossia
'The
bitter truth is' frames the narrator’s conclusion as definitive. That is, the
narrator a rhetorical move that shuts down any further or potential
alternative.
Heteroglossia 'I ran away…not even caring about my two
younger siblings...' raises and denies expectation. That is, the expected
norm is to escape with other siblings. The narrator, clearly, counters this
norm. Instead, they use their escape to reinforce their self judgement and
the extreme nature of their situation. |
Force '…my parents
routine abandonment split me emotionally' This expression metaphorises
damage. The verb split is a metaphor that represent psychological damage. The clause
'Not even my two younger siblings' sharpens a
moral weight. That is, it shows the speaker’s guilt in failing her
siblings. |
|
Excerpt 3 ‘… rocked my
already dysfunctional nervous system…' ‘hmmm… for
where? I didn’t o' |
Affect The
narrator’s use of the exclamation 'Kai!', first shows dissatisfaction and
grief. ‘Kai’ as used in this context, is a raw culturally grounded outburst of sadness. Judgement When the
narrator expressed ' …hoping I will heal… and find joy… hmmm… for where? I
didn’t o’ indicates complete failure of their own strategy (success) to heal. |
Monoglossia: Here, the
speaker’s final verdict 'I didn’t o' states failure as fact. That is, the
narrator is stating that, the societal belief that success brings happiness
is not true especially in their case. |
Force The
phrase 'Sharp pain' is used to amplify
the intensity of pain experienced by the narrator after their mother’s death.
It (experiencing psychological pain in a physical way) the narrator’s grief.
The word 'rocked' amplifies destabilization. That is, the type of
psychological experience that threatens the speaker’s wellbeing. This
metaphor is also employed to make the listener feel their physical pain. |
|
Excerpt 4 ‘My body
didn’t feel like my own. It was just a vessel inhabited that echoed with
fear.’ ‘ … Haa!!
That alone dey kill me for inside.’ |
Affect The asyndetic use of word list like empty,
worthless, depressed… performs negative overload on the narrator. It shows
the speaker’s dissatisfaction of their emotional state. Judgement The entire
part of this narrative is already judged as abandonment, shame and disgrace.
|
Monoglossia The list of
negatives is presented as a
monoglossia fact. It refuses any interpretation of their internal reality.
Meaning, it does not give room for a dialogic interaction. |
Force The
phrase '… echoed with fear' is
employed to intensify and heighten emotion. Force Code
switching to Nigerian Pidgin English “… dey kill me for inside” shows the
peak of emotional force. That is, it expresses a level of internal torment
that Standard English may not be able to capture. |
|
Except 5 ‘These are
not minor feats' ‘Healing is a
process, a journey but it is worth every bit of the work it takes.’ |
Appreciation The positive
lexical choice 'wins' re-values mundane acts. This marks the narrator’s start
of agentive reappraisal. Also, the expression ‘Healing is a process…'
appreciates the narrator’s entire process of cognitive restructure. |
Heteroglossia After
introducing their wins, the narrator further expands the dialogic space by
using “ I mean” as a clear entertain resource to signal and actively invite the listener to consider
their perspective of small wins. The
narrator thus, linguistically enacts their reintegration into a community of
understanding and models the discursive practices of resilience. Monoglossic The
concluding statement is delivered as a form of wisdom. That is, a secured
monoglossic truth that the narrator
has earned through experience. |
Focus ‘…not minor
feats' explains clearly the value of the narrator’s actions, challenges their
potential diminishment and elevates them to a significant accomplishment. 'worth every
bit of work' This clause is employed
to quantify the extent of work put in place to achieve positive reappraisal. |
Table
1 Analysis for Appraisal Resources
5.0 Discussion
This
study describe the patterns of evaluative language in a mental health recovery
narrative through the linguistic model of Appraisal Theory. The analysis shows
that the narrator's journey is not just a linear shift from negative to
positive content. Rather, it is a fundamental restructuring of their discursive
strategies across the three interrelated systems of Attitude, Engagement and
Graduation. As detailed in Table 1, the early excerpts (1-4) show a consistent
pattern of negative Attitude, contractive Engagement, and high-force
Graduation. These are initial construction of depressive state that is
characterised by the convergence of these systems.
The narrator employs monoglossic assertions to
present her suffering as an unassailable reality e.g., "I was raised in a
very violent home", which is then intensified through graduating resources
of Force e.g., "sharp pain," "echoed with fear" and
sharpened Focus e.g., "all sorts" of harassment. This creates a
discursive world where profound negative Affect and harsh Judgment are rendered
as the only possible truth, contractively shutting down alternative
interpretations through phrases like "The bitter truth is..."
Whereas excerpt
5 demonstrates a strategic shift to positive Appreciation, expansive
Engagement, and the repurposing of Graduation to value recovery." The
narrative's turning point is signaled by a strategic opening of this dialogic
space. The introduction of a benefactor's voice through attribution "‘omo
mi (my child), this will not happen to you again’" serves as a critical
heteroglossic expansion, planting a counter-narrative of hope and community.
Furthermore, the narrator's use of entertain "Imagine, asking
neighbors..." functions interpersonally to build alignment with the
listener. It is used to foster shared empathy that was absent in their isolated
emotive state.
This
dialogic opening enables the core work of recovery. That is, the recalibration
of appraisal. The narrator agentively re-graduates their experience, shifting
the focus of intensification from their pain to agency. This explicitly
sharpens the value of mundane acts by framing them as “wins" and insisting
they are "not minor feats." This represents a conscious, linguistic
act of cognitive restructuring, where positive Appreciation is systematically
deployed to build a new self-concept.
Therefore, the
analysis demonstrates that "rewriting appraisal" is a
multidimensional rhetorical achievement. That research proves that the
narrator's recovery was demonstrated by their ability to skillfully reshape the
very language she used to evaluate her life. The narrator persuasively rebuilt
their identity across multiple linguistic levels (attitude, engagement and
graduation). This process transforms their story from one of depression into
that of agency and hope. In addition, healing is linguistically indexed not by
the eradication of negative evaluation but by the synergistic development of a
more complex interpersonal stance. That is, one that incorporates supportive
voices of engagement, consciously recalibrates the value of personal actions of
graduation, and thereby constructs a resilient identity capable of positive
self-appreciation
6.0 Conclusion
This
article has demonstrated that the linguistic construction of mental health
recovery is a tripartite process involving Attitude, Engagement, and
Graduation. The research reveals that the narrator's journey from a depressive
defined identity to one of agency is expressed through a discernible discursive
shift. That is from a monologic, intensified presentation of suffering to a
dialogic narrative that invites empathy, and from the negative graduation of
pain to the positive graduation of personal accomplishment. The theoretical
implication of this study is that Appraisal Theory, in its full configuration,
provides a detailed model for deconstructing the linguistic mechanics of lived
experience that computational models or isolated thematic analysis overlook.
Practically, these findings suggest that clinicians and support networks can be
attuned to these discursive markers such as a patient's increasing use of
heteroglossic resources or the positive graduation of small achievements as
indicators of developing resilience. This study recommends that future research
may apply this integrated Appraisal framework to longitudinal or comparative
studies to further validate these linguistic patterns as markers of therapeutic
progress across diverse cultural and clinical contexts. This analysis affirms
that recovery is not only a psychological process but also a discursive
accomplishment, realized through the deliberate and strategic reworking of
one's evaluative language.
References
Abubakar,
A. S., & Abubakar, S. (2024). Prevalence of and factors associated with
depression among patients attending primary and secondary health care
facilities in Kano State, Nigeria. Medtigo Journal of Medicine. https://doi.org/10.63096/medtigo3062243
Adebayo,
A. O. (2024). Social media discourses of Nigerian social affairs: A critical
appraisal of YouTube vloggers’ panacea hypotheses for national recovery.
African Identities, 23(3), 896–915.https://doi.org/10.1080/14725843.2024.2419052
Adeleke,
O. T., Opadola, O. A., Ojo, M. M., Samuel-Ajayi, Y. A., Adeleke, O. V., &
Adedeji, A. S. (n.d.). A cross-sectional study of anxiety and depression in a
cohort of Nigerian undergraduates. African Health Review. https://doi.org/10.30442/ahr.1101-03-267
American
Psychiatric Association. (2013). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental
disorders (5th ed.). https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.books.9780890425596
Banjo,
O., Eruchie, E., & Agbo, M. (2025). Comparative review of digital mental
health platforms in Africa: Insights from FriendnPal and other models of care. International
Journal of Research and Innovation in Social Science, 9(9), 6722–6728. https://doi.org/10.47772/IJRISS.2025.909000550
Bharat,
D. (2023). Key challenges and opportunities for podcasters in the digital age:
A critical review. https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:0168-ssoar-87495-3
Dajur,
P. (2023, June 3). Election or selection: Theological appraisal of elections
in Nigeria. Church of Nigeria (Anglican Communion). https://anglican-nig.org/election-or-selection-theological-appraisal-of-elections-in-nigeria-by-the-ven-dr-paul-dajur/
Fadele,
K. P., et al. (2023). Mental health challenges in Nigeria: Bridging the
gap between demand and resources. Global Mental Health 11, e29. https://doi.org/10.1017/gmh.2024.19
Federal
Republic of Nigeria. (2021). National Mental Health Act (Official
Gazette No. 229, Vol. 109). Government Printer.
Hari,
J. (2018). Lost connections: Uncovering the real causes of depression: and
the unexpected solutions. Bloomsbury Publishing.
Haruna,
U., Mohammed, A. R., & Braimah, M. (2025). Understanding the burden of
depression, anxiety, and stress among first-year undergraduate students. BMC
Psychiatry, 25(1), Article 632. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12888-025-07069-8
Hood,
S. (2010). Appraising research: Evaluation in academic writing. Palgrave
Macmillan.
Ibigbami,
O. I., Akinsulore, A., Opakunle, T., Seun-Fadipe, C., Oginni, O. A., Okorie, V.
O., ... Adewuya, A. (2022). Psychological distress, anxiety, depression, and
associated factors among Nigerian healthcare workers during COVID-19 pandemic:
A cross-sectional study. International Journal of Public Health, 67,
1604835.
Institute
for Health Metrics and Evaluation. (2024). Mental health. https://www.healthdata.org/research-analysis/diseases-injuries/mental-disorders
Jidong,
D. E., Husain, N., Francis, C., et al. (2021). Mental health experiences of
mothers in Jos, Nigeria: An interpretative phenomenological analysis. SAGE
Open Medicine, 9. https://doi.org/10.1177/2050312120970714
Kas,
M. J. H., et al. (2025). Towards a consensus roadmap for a new diagnostic
framework for mental disorders. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 26(2),
89-103.
Kola,
L. (2020). Global mental health and COVID-19. The Lancet Psychiatry, 7(8),
655–657. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2215-0366(20)30235-2
Federal
Government of Nigeria. (1948). Lunacy Ordinance (Vol. IV, Cap. 121).
Government Printer.
Lee,
J. E., Goh, M. L., & Yeo, S. F. (2023). Mental health awareness of
secondary school students: Mediating roles of knowledge on mental health,
knowledge on professional help, and attitude towards mental health. Heliyon,
9(3), e14512. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e14512
Lyons,
M., Aksayli, N. D., & Brewer, G. (2018). Mental distress and language use:
Linguistic analysis of discussion forum posts. Computers in Human Behavior,
87, 207–211.
Martin,
J. R. (2003). Introduction. Text, 23(2), 171–181.
Martin,
J. R., & White, P. R. R. (2005). The language of evaluation: Appraisal
in English. Palgrave Macmillan.
National
Alliance on Mental Illness. (2024). Mental health statistics in the United
States. Retrieved from https://www.nami.org
National
Alliance on Mental Illness [@nami]. (2024, May 15). May is Mental Health
Awareness Month, but our work to support the millions of Americans affected by
mental illness continues all year [Post]. Instagram. https://www.instagram.com/p/C7B8J-2uJxQ/
Ogunwale,
A., Ogunlesi, A. O., Shepherd, S. M., Serpa, K. I., & Singh, J. P. (2021).
The handbook of forensic mental health in Africa (1st ed.). Routledge.
O’Reilly,
M., & Lester, J. (2017). Examining mental health through social
constructionism: The language of mental health. Palgrave Macmillan
Onakun,
J. (Host). (2024). Looking for validation: My journey through depression and
anxiety [Audio podcast episode]. In Let's Talk Mental Health. Spotify.
Oteíza,
T. (2017). The appraisal framework and discourse analysis. In T. Bartlett &
G. O’Grady (Eds.), The Routledge handbook of systemic functional linguistics
(pp. 460–472). Routledge
Owolabi,
O. B., Lawrence, U. O., Falade, J. A., Ikeookwu, O. K., Aderounmu, E. A., &
Kelechi, C. S. (2024). The role of media influencers in using their platforms
to sensitize Nigerian students on mental health. International Journal of
Research and Innovation in Social Science, 8(9), 2232-2245.
Rahman,
M., Ahmed, R., Moitra, M., Damschroder, L., Brownson, R., Chorpita, B., et al.
(2021). Mental distress and human rights violations during COVID-19: A rapid
review of the evidence informing rights, mental health needs, and public policy
around vulnerable populations. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 11, 603875. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2020.603875
Saied,
A. A. (2023). Nigeria’s National Mental Health Act 2021: Any challenges ahead? The
Lancet, 401(10381), 997–999. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(23)00345-8
Sakai,
H., & Lam, S. S. (202). Large language models for healthcare text
classification: A systematic review. arXiv. https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.01159v1
Samsudin,
S., Ismail, R., Daud, M. N. S., & Yahya, S. (2024). The prevalence and
underlying factors of mental health disorders in Malaysian youth. Journal of
Affective Disorders Reports, 15, 100706. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jadr.2023.100706
Spytska,
L. (2024). Anxiety and depressive personality disorders in the modern world. Acta
Psychologica, 246, 104285. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actpsy.2024.104285
TurnTable
Charts. (2023, December 9). Nigerian voices on the rise: Spotify spotlight
homegrown podcasters. Turntable Charts. https://www.turntablecharts.com/news/1180
Ugwu,
A., & Baiye, B. (2022, January 19). From the Lunacy Act to the first Mental
Health Act in Nigeria: Five takeaways. Nigeria Health Watch. https://nigeriahealthwatch.com/from-the-lunacy-act-to-the-first-mental-health-act-in-nigeria-five-takeaways/
UNC
Health Caldwell. (2022, December 8). If health is wealth, why do so many
ignore mental health? https://www.caldwellmemorial.org/
Viavonu,
S. (2025, February 19). The podcast boom in Nigeria: An era of noise or
knowledge? Culture Custodian.
https://culturecustodian.com/the-great-decline-of-meaningful-conversation-in-nigerias-media-space/
Wijtenburg,
S. A., et al. (2025). NIMH perspectives on future directions in neuroimaging
for psychiatric research. American Journal of Psychiatry, 182(1), 15-28.
World
Health Organization. (2016). mhGAP intervention guide for mental,
neurological and substance use disorders in non-specialized health settings:
Mental health Gap Action Programme (mhGAP) – Version 2.0. World Health
Organization. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789241549790
World
Health Organization. (2021). World mental health atlas 2020. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240036703
World
Health Organization. (2021, October 24). Adolescent mental health. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/adolescent-mental-health
World
Health Organization. (2022). Mental health: Strengthening our response.
https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/mental-health-strengthening-our-response
World
Health Organization. (2024, March 8). Clinical descriptions and diagnostic
requirements for ICD-11 mental, behavioural and neurodevelopmental disorders
(CDDR). https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240076457
World
Health Organization. (2025, September 2). Over a billion people living with
mental health conditions – services require urgent scale-up. https://www.who.int/news/item/over-a-billion-people-living-with-mental-health-conditions-services-require-urgent-scale-up
0 Comments