Cite this article as: Ali-Momoh, B. O., Akomolafe, O. S., Adeola, K. J., Ogunya, O., Adebayo, K., Bamigbola, B. T., Akomolafe, F. O. & Olubo, M. V. (2025). Synergizing Forensic Accounting and Whistle-Blowing in Nigeria’s Banking Sector: Legal Frameworks and Fraud Detection. Zamfara International Journal of Humanities, 4(1), 111-125. www.doi.org/10.36349/zamijoh.2025.v04i01.012.
SYNERGIZING
FORENSIC ACCOUNTING AND WHISTLE-BLOWING IN NIGERIA’S BANKING SECTOR: LEGAL
FRAMEWORKS AND FRAUD DETECTION
By
ALI-MOMOH, Betty
Oluwayemisi
AKOMOLAFE,
Olayiwola Samson
ADEOLA, Kayode
Joseph
OGUNYA, Omoniyi
ADEBAYO, Kehinde
BAMIGBOLA,
Babajide Tolu
AKOMOLAFE,
Funmilola Olubunmi
OLUBO, Muyiwa
Victor
1-8 Department of
Accounting, Faculty of Management Sciences, Federal University Oye-Ekiti, Ekiti
State, Nigeria
Abstract: In the wake of the
increasing global trend of corporate collapses, this study explores the
intersection of legal systems, forensic accounting, and whistleblowing policies
as mechanisms for enhancing fraud detection in Nigeria's banking sector. The
study specifically explores how systems assist in detecting financial
misconduct among Deposit Money Banks (DMBs). The general objective was to
investigate the synergy between whistleblowing and forensic accounting
practice, as guided by current legal frameworks, and ascertain their joint
effectiveness in unveiling corporate fraud in Nigeria's banking industry. The
study adopted a survey research design in which structured questionnaires were
administered to 83 forensic accountants practicing in Nigeria's DMBs. A census
sampling technique was utilized to covered the entire population due to the
small and specialized population. Quantitative data analysis, including
correlation procedures, was utilized to determine the strength and statistical
significance of the whistleblowing practices and forensic fraud investigation
relationship. Findings shows that there is statistically significant
correlation between whistleblowing activities and the effectiveness of forensic
accounting in fraud detection at 5% level of significance (p < 0.05).
Further, the study indicates the mandatory role played by good corporate
governance, effective internal controls, and advanced forensic accounting
techniques in facilitating fraud detection. The findings concluded that whistleblowing
and forensic accounting supported by appropriate legal and institutional
frameworks, are crucial for promoting transparency and financial integrity in
the banking sector. Traditional accounting processes overlook financial
malpractices, whereas forensic processes combined with protected whistleblower
disclosures offer a better fraud detection mechanism. The study recommends the
enactment and enforcement of robust whistleblower protection legislation with
integration of emerging technology such as artificial intelligence, machine
learning, and blockchain to speed up and enhance the precision of fraud
detection in Nigerian banks should be established.
Keywords: Forensic
Accounting, Whistle-blowing, Internal Control, Corporate Governance, and
Auditor Independence.
INTRODUCTION
Fraud and fraudulent
activities are so prevalent in the Nigerian banking system from the most junior
staff to the most senior personnel. Huge frauds do happen in banks, even
amongst employees and operational staff who commit fraud to their level of
position (Apalowowa et al., 2025). Vutum et al. (2025) an increase in
fraudulent activities, these scams have an impact on everyone from the
developing economies to the banks, investors, and ultimately on the
individuals. Therefore, fraud can be defined as the intentional and secret
devaluation of an asset with the intent to profit from it (Shehu, 2025). The
recent high rates of bank collapses have cast into doubt the credibility of the
traditional auditing process as it relates to the Nigerian banking system. Given
the prevalence of bank fraud and bank collapses, the traditional audit process
has come under question for its reliability (Apalowowa et al., 2023a). Corporate governance refers to the structures,
processes, and practices that ensure an organization is directed and controlled
in a way that aligns with its objectives and stakeholders' interests. Apalowowa
et al. (2023) opined that auditor
independence is a cornerstone of the auditing profession,
essential for ensuring the reliability and integrity of financial statements
and maintaining public trust in the financial reporting process. Using
forensic auditing expertise appears to be a magic bullet that will help to
combat fraud and show the preventive role of conventional auditing to become
effective and build integrity attributes for an auditor. Forensic auditing
gained prominence as a result. Felix (2022) posits that forensic auditing is
thought to have developed in response to specific newly fraud-related cases.
Financial fraud is growing, and forensic auditing must now be included in the
arsenal of instruments required for the successful investigation and
prosecution of those responsible for illegal activity (Apalowowa et al., 2023a;
Oladejo & Jack,
2020).
Statement of the Problem
The fraud scandals
that came closest to bringing down the corporate world were those involving
Enron, Arthur Anderson, and WorldCom. These events showed how badly forensic
auditing is needed because the frequent fraud cases in Nigerian Deposit Money
Banks have completely destroyed customers' trust in banks. The general public's
trust in higher institutions in Nigeria and citizens' trust in them have also
made people doubt the honesty of the management, staff, internal auditors, and
even external auditors. The fraud committed by Heritage Bank's executives in
Nigeria in 2024 led to the bank's demise. Examining the interplay between
whistle-blowing and regulatory compliance in the discovery of fraud within the
banking industry.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Theoretical Review
The following two theories were considered: Forensic accounting theory and
strain theory. However, the study is hinged on forensic accounting theory as
the best theory that explains the preventive measures in safeguarding both
financial and non-financial assets of an organization.
Forensic
accounting theory
Forensic accounting theory looks at how the accounting and
non-accounting decisions made at the start, during, and at the end of the
investigation process affect the choice of forensic detection methods and
techniques used, and the interpretation of the findings of forensic
investigation. The examined studies concur that forensic accounting is not an
impartial method. Nonetheless, the subtleties differ. Apalowowa et al. (2023)
and Daraojimba et al. (2023) underscore the integration of investigative choices
within contextual judgements, whilst Alshurafat et al. and Al Shbeil et al.
highlight the ethical justifications and ramifications for justice and equity
in forensic procedures. The unifying factor is the acknowledgement that both
technical and ethical factors influence forensic accounting methods. A
significant void remains in experimentally examining how accounting and
non-accounting actions affect particular forensic outcomes in various legal or
cultural contexts. Alharasis et al. (2023) assert that forensic accounting
theory suggests that the choice of methods or techniques used to detect
creative accounting or manipulations in financial reporting, and the outcome of
using such methods or techniques, reflect the accounting and non-accounting
decisions that were taken into consideration by the forensic accountant or
investigator. Some working assumptions are that the humane objective of a
forensic investigation exercise is to identify and uncover unresolved issues
and recommend corrective actions that discourage such behavior from occurring
again (Alshurafat et al., 2023). Such corrective actions include the imposition
of fines, and imprisonment. Without this assumption, forensic investigators may
seek the downfall of the corporation or the individual they are investigating
for criminal suspicion (Al Shbeil et al., 2022). Therefore, this assumption is
crucial because it eliminates the personal judgmental bias of the forensic
investigator, and prevents the personal bias of forensic investigators from
interfering with the forensic investigation.
Strain Theory
Strain Theory was introduced by Robert K. Merton, which assumes that
individuals feel strain and pressure when they cannot achieve socially accepted
go51als through legitimate means (Ogbu, 2017). Based on this strain theory, as
a result of economic crime, individuals may turn to fraud or embezzlement when
they feel economically blocked or incapable of reaching success through
‘legitimate’ means (Audu & Garba, 2021; Adamu & Bala, 2020). Under the
assumption that limited legitimate opportunities obstruct the achievement of
culturally endorsed goals, Choi and Kim, 2020 argued that “strained or
pressured individuals turn to various forms of deviant and/or criminal behavior
as a means to accomplish their wants. Strain theory explains that there is a
cultural standard of desirable goals in society, for example, financial
success; a good education; and social standing; and this set of goals is
largely encouraged and supported in a given society (Oyebade, 2016). Yet not
everyone has the same access to resources and opportunities to attain these
goals through legitimate means such as education, employment and legal business
practices (Efiong, 2012). Strain occurs when individuals face impediments to
obtaining such goals. The theory helps to understand the prevalence of
work-related crimes, such as fraud, embezzlement, or tax evasion, that might
take place because people feel pressured or frustrated for not being able,
through legitimate means, to access success (Choi & Kim 2020; Omonyemen et
al., 2017). For example, a financially struggling, non-promoted financial
manager might commit fraud in order to attain the financial prosperity he
believes necessary for social acceptance or for self-.fulfillment.
Conceptual Review
Concept of Forensic Accounting
Afriyie et al.
(2023) articulates that forensic accounting is a specialized
field within accounting that focuses on the application of accounting
principles and techniques to investigate and analyze financial data for legal
purposes. It combines accounting, auditing, and investigative skills to uncover
and resolve issues related to financial fraud, misconduct, and disputes (Felix,
2022). Forensic accountants play a crucial role in legal proceedings, helping
to provide clarity and evidence in cases involving financial crimes,
litigation, and regulatory compliance (Eiya & Otalor, 2013). Forensic
accountants use various techniques to identify irregularities and anomalies in
financial records that may indicate fraudulent activities and employ methods
such as data analysis, forensic analysis of financial documents, and interviews
to uncover evidence of fraud (Apalowowa et al., 2023).
Whistle-Blowers
A whistleblower is an individual who reports misconduct,
fraud, and abuse within an organization to authorities or external entities,
the misconduct includes a wide range of activities, such as financial fraud,
environmental violations, workplace harassment, or safety breaches (Abdullahi
& Adamu, 2022). Whistleblowers may be employees, contractors, and even
outsiders who have insider knowledge of the wrongdoing (Yahaya et al., 2024).
The act of whistleblowing is often driven by a sense of moral duty and ethical
responsibility (Usman & Bala, 2021). Whistleblowers frequently come forward
because they feel that their conscience cannot tolerate the continuation of
harmful and illegal activities they have observed (Yahaya & Musa, 2021).
Their disclosures lead to critical investigations, corrective actions, and
reforms that prevent further damage and uphold the rule of law. According to
Miceli et al. (1985) whistle-blowing is defined14 as the disclosure by a
current or former member of an organisation of unlawful, immoral, or
illegitimate acts under their employers’ control to persons or organisations
that may be able to take action.
Internal Controls
Stephen
et al. (2025) assert that internal control means a systematic process
implemented by an organization's management and personnel designed to provide
reasonable assurance regarding the achievement of objectives related to
operational effectiveness and efficiency, reliable financial reporting, and compliance
with applicable laws and regulations. Adeleke et al., (2019), posit that the
primary purpose of internal control is to safeguard assets, ensure the accuracy
and completeness of financial records, and prevent and detect errors, fraud,
and other irregularities. An effective internal control system encompasses a
range of activities and practices that are integrated into the organization's
operations (Apalowowa et al., 2023b). Internal control
is an essential tool
for ensuring that an organization's operations are conducted in a manner that
is consistent with its goals and regulatory requirements.
Corporate
Governance
Corporate governance involves the interplay between various
stakeholders, including shareholders, boards of directors, management,
employees, customers, suppliers, and the wider community (Ogbu, 2017). The
effectiveness of corporate governance is crucial for maintaining investor
confidence, ensuring compliance with laws and regulations, and fostering a
culture of integrity and responsibility within the organization. Oyebade (2016) postulates that corporate governance
is the structures, processes, and practices that ensure an organization is
directed and controlled in a way that aligns with its objectives and
stakeholders' interests. Okonta Nnamdi (2025) postulate that corporate
governance encompasses the framework of rules, relationships, systems, and processes
within and by which authority is exercised and controlled in corporations.
Auditor's
Independence
Apalowowa et al (2023) is a cornerstone of the
auditing profession, essential for ensuring the reliability and integrity of
financial statements and maintaining public trust in the financial reporting
process. Nirali and Dharini (2023) posit that auditor’s independence is a critical
element of the auditing profession that ensures the reliability, objectivity,
and credibility of financial reporting. As posited by Akinbowale, et al.,
(2020) cited in Oyebade (2016) that adhering to stringent independence requirements,
implementing effective safeguards, and addressing potential conflicts of
interest, auditors can maintain the trust of stakeholders and contribute to the
integrity of financial markets and corporate governance.
Empirical Review
Apalowowa (2025) examined the connection between
white-collar fraud and whistleblower investigation. The research employs a
survey technique with data obtained directly from the respondents; the
population under investigation comprise 83 forensic auditors from the southwest
of Nigeria. Census Sampling Technique was employed in the selection of the
entire population to be examined. His results indicate that although the
efficiency of forensic audits is positively related to whistleblowing, internal
controls, and corporate governance, none of the variables produced
statistically significant outcomes at conventional levels (p > 0.05). The
values of the z-statistics of 1.2521 for corporate governance, 1.1783 for
internal controls, and 1.1647 for whistle-blowing tell us that the
relationships are a result of random fluctuation rather than actual
cause-and-effect relationships.
Apalowowa et al. (2025) had studied the preventive function
of the forensic auditor with the introduction of forensic auditing. The
research employed purposive sampling techniques using a survey approach based
on a questionnaire. The study population was 210 staff of the three state
government-owned colleges in Ondo State who were employed in the Audit
Departments (Source: Attendance Register, 2025). The research covers 120 senior
staff with ICAN and ANAN certification. Their findings indicate that responsive
planning methods are statistically insignificant, but robust internal control
and managerial supervision are statistically significant, with p-values of
0.0000 and 0.00105, respectively.
Vutumu et al. (2025) discuss the complementary functions of
forensic accounting and internal controls in avoiding fraud in the Nigerian
public sector. The research purports to assess the interaction between the
Fraud Pentagon Model and the COSO framework in fraud risk prevention. A
quantitative methodology was adopted, and primary data were gathered from 385
finance, accounting, auditing, and forensics professionals in federal
ministries and organizations. A Likert-scale questionnaire was applied to measure
the effectiveness of the internal controls, forensic accounting practices, and
the occurrence of fraud risk factors. Descriptive statistical analysis was
conducted with the help of SPSS software to establish trends and correlations
in the data. The study supported the occurrence of all five factors of the
Pentagon fraud model: pressure (mean 3.50), opportunity (3.31), motivation
(3.47), capability (3.34), and personal ethics (3.47), which suggested a high
likelihood of fraud. The control components were moderately strong, whereby
control measures (mean = 3.50) and monitoring (3.49) were the strongest,
followed by risk assessment (3.27) and communication practices (3.36) as
relatively lower. The forensic accounting techniques contributed significantly
to fraud prevention through delegation of reliance on control systems (3.42),
number of reviews of digital fraud (3.39), and submission to ethical philosophy
(3.39).
Okonta and Nnamdi (2025) examine the application of
Artificial Intelligence (AI) in fraud investigations for fraud detection in
Nigerian enterprises. With traditional methods falling short in the era of
mounting complexity in fraudulent activities posing a threat to business
survival, the study examines the manner in which AI technology can facilitate
improvement in investigative techniques. This study employs a documentary
method in examining the use of data analytics, machine learning algorithms, and
predictive modeling in enhancing the speed, accuracy, and efficiency of fraud
detection. In spite of the limitations in implementation in the Nigerian
scenario, evidence suggests that AI-based forensic techniques enhance the
efficacy of fraud detection and prevention via active surveillance.
Atmadja
et al. (2024), decided the impact of internal control frameworks, consistency
with human asset guidelines, and abilities on bookkeeping misrepresentation in
the territorial monetary administration of the Gianyar Rule in Indonesia. The
exploration strategy utilizes quantitative and information examination methods,
including various relapses and examination of a survey replied to by the staff
of the territorial work unit in Gianyar Rule. Examining in this study utilizes
Non-Likelihood testing with a Purposive Inspecting strategy, their discoveries
uncovered that the inward control framework adversely affects bookkeeping
extortion, administrative consistency likewise adversely influences bookkeeping
misrepresentation, and human asset skill affects bookkeeping extortion in the
Provincial Work Unit in Gianyar Rule.
Romero-Carazas (2024) analyzes forensic auditing and the use
of artificial intelligence through a bibliometric analysis in Scopus and a
systematic literature review. The samples were documents selected using Boolean
operators with keywords in English (Forensic and auditing, artificial and
Intelligence), analyzed in Excel and VOS viewer. This research points out that
forensic auditing and the use of artificial intelligence have advanced, in the
variety of topics covered, the prominence of perpetrators, and the
accessibility of crucial data. Their findings maintain the quality and
integrity of their work, forensic auditors must adapt to technological
advances, train in the use of artificial intelligence, and collaborate with
other specialists and professionals.
Odeyemi et al. (2024) delve into the contemporary landscape
of forensic accounting, focusing on the integration of cutting-edge
technologies and digital methodologies. It underlines the significance of
forensic accountants staying abreast of technological advancements to
effectively navigate the intricate terrain of financial fraud in the modern
era. The Review encapsulates the primary themes explored in the review,
including the application of data analytics, artificial intelligence,
blockchain, and machine learning in forensic accounting practices. It
highlights the dynamic nature of financial crimes, requiring forensic
accountants to adopt agile and innovative approaches to keep pace with
fraudulent activities conducted through digital channels.
Olutimehin et al. (2024) evaluate current corporate
governance practices in Nigerian enterprises, emphasizing strengths such as
board composition, financial reporting, and compliance mechanisms, while also
addressing weaknesses such as board independence, executive compensation, and
risk management frameworks. It explores the impact of cultural, social, and
economic factors on governance dynamics, acknowledging the need for
context-specific approaches tailored to Nigeria's unique business environment.
Investing in stakeholder engagement initiatives that prioritize dialogue,
collaboration, and shared value creation, aligning business objectives with
societal needs and expectations. Incorporating technology-driven solutions to
facilitate real-time communication and feedback loops with stakeholders,
leveraging digital platforms for transparent and responsive engagement.
Chidi et al. (2024) aims at evaluating the impact of
internal control systems on the operational efficiency of supermarkets by
examining factors such as periodic job description updates, documentation and
record retention, time and leave reporting, division of labor, physical
restrictions to unauthorized units, and firewall security. The research design
employed in this study is a quantitative approach, and data was collected
through survey questionnaires. The total population used for this study is 192
staff in the main Supermarkets in Awka, Anambra state. The sample size of the
study was determined using Krejcie and Morgan (1970) formula. Multi-Linear
regression technique was employed in analyzing the data to determine the extent
of relationship that exists between the dependent and independent variables.
Their study discovered that various components of internal control systems
significantly influence operational efficiency.
Okwuokei (2024) examines the role of whistleblowing in
combating corruption in Nigeria and underscores the critical need for enabling
laws to safeguard and empower whistleblowers. The analysis includes a
discussion on the dual nature of whistleblowing its potential benefits in
exposing wrongdoing and the severe risks faced by whistleblowers. The absence
of protective legislation has left whistleblowers vulnerable, often facing
harassment, intimidation, and loss of employment. Drawing parallels with the United
States, where comprehensive laws such as the Whistleblower Protection Act
provide robust safeguards, the paper advocates for the urgent enactment of
similar legislation in Nigeria.
Yahaya et al. (2024) assess the impact of the whistleblowing
policy on corruption levels in Niger State. The study employs a mixed-methods
approach, combining qualitative and quantitative research methods using a
survey research approach by adopting a primary source of data collection in the
use of questionnaires. The study's participants are staff of stakeholders,
including government officials, whistleblowers, and representatives from civil
society organizations in Niger state simple random sampling was used to sample
several 300 respondents for the study. The study utilizes multiple regressions
adopting simple percentage, mean, rank, and frequency count for data analysis.
Their findings of reveal whistleblowing policy has reduced corruption in the
Niger state, whistleblowing policy has been in deterring corrupt practices and
increased transparency and accountability in government institutions in Niger
state.
Apalowowa et al. (2023) investigated a study on how
forensic accounting practices affect fraud investigation, fraud prevention, and
fraud detection in Nigeria's State Pension Board. Used primary sources of data
to implement a survey research design. 186 senior employees of the State
Pension Board in the three states that were chosen made up the study's
population, both stratified sampling and census sampling techniques were
utilized in the investigation, and the Ordinary Least Square Regression
approach was used. Their findings showed that forensic accounting significantly
affects the investigation, prevention, and detection of fraud. The results also
showed that fraud prevention and detection are statistically significantly
influenced by internal audit, accountability, and transparency techniques.
Wokeh (2020) examined the effect of internal control on the
financial performance of listed deposit money banks in Nigeria. The
triangulated research design was employed for the study. The population of the
study consists of two hundred and twenty (220) respondents drawn from the
thirteen (13) listed deposit money banks. Multiple regression analysis was used
to test the formulated hypothesis computed with the aid of Stata12 statistical
software. The study revealed a negative and insignificant effect of the control
environment on the net profit margin of listed deposit money banks in Nigeria
and the existence of a positive but insignificant effect of risk assessment on
the net profit margin of listed deposit money banks in Nigeria.
Gap in the
Literature
Due to the extreme
prevalence of fraud, auditing and investigation methods are no longer useful
for identifying, stopping, and minimizing the fraud faces every establishment.
The most frequently cited fraud scandals that nearly brought down the business world
were those involving Enron, Arthur Anderson, and WorldCom (Olutimehin et al.,
2024; Odeyemi et al., 2024; Yahaya et al., 2024; Apalowowa et al., 2023; &
Wokeh, 2020). Examining
the gap in the literature on forensic accounting and whistleblowers as investigative
tools for identifying irregularities in the Nigerian banking industry involves
understanding several key areas where previous research studies lacking and
this study expanded. The existing research focus separately on forensic
accounting and whistleblowing. Meanwhile this study integrate both forensic
accounting and whistleblowing mechanisms as complementary tools in the Nigerian
banking sector, and these two approaches are combined effectively to improve
detection and prevention of financial irregularities. Adequacy of training and
skill development programs for forensic accountants and potential
whistleblowers in Nigeria’s banking sector are not established. By addressing
these gaps, this study contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of how
forensic accounting and whistleblowing leveraged to improve financial integrity
in Nigeria’s banking industry.
Methodology
This study employed a survey approach, utilising a
structured questionnaire to gather primary data from forensic accountants in
Deposit Money Banks (DMBs) in Nigeria. The utilisation of a questionnaire was
considered suitable owing to the sensitive nature of fraud-related subjects,
which renders respondents hesitant to disclose records or furnish information
in open or unstructured formats. The research concentrated on Deposit Money
Banks (DMBs), particularly commercial banks. This sector was chosen because to
recent prominent fraud cases, notably the Heritage Bank Plc scandal, which
exposed systemic weaknesses in internal controls and whistle-blowing procedures
inside Nigeria's banking system. The target audience consisted of eighty-three
(83) forensic accountants engaged in various Deposit Money Banks throughout
Nigeria. These experts engage in fraud detection and forensic investigations,
enabling them to evaluate the function and efficacy of forensic accounting and
whistle-blowing systems. Due to the very limited population size, the study
utilised the census sampling technique, which entails the inclusion of all
population members in the sample. This methodology was warranted as it allows
the research to obtain a thorough and representative viewpoint from all
accessible professionals in the domain, hence mitigating sampling bias and
enhancing the validity of the results. Data was gathered through a structured
questionnaire aimed at eliciting responses regarding the impact of forensic
accounting processes and whistle-blowing methods on mitigating fraud within the
Nigerian banking system. The tool comprised closed-ended items, assessed by a
four-point Likert-type scale organised as follows: 4 = Strongly Agree; 3 Agree;
2 = Disagree; 1 = Strongly Disagree. The choice of four-point scale was
deliberately selected to exclude a neutral response choice, so prompting
respondents to adopt a definitive position on each assertion, which is
especially beneficial when addressing subjective yet sensitive topics such as
fraud control and ethical practices. Notwithstanding, the application of the
census technique and the utilisation of a meticulously designed instrument
guaranteed the preservation of data quality and representativeness, rendering
the findings robust and contextually pertinent.
Data Analysis
Results of the regression analysis on the data collected from forensic accountants in Deposit Money Banks (DMBs) in Nigeria provide an understanding of the relationship between the whistle-blowing mechanism and forensic accounting procedures in enhancing fraud detection and financial soundness. The positive coefficient indicates that whistle-blowing has a significant influence on the effectiveness of forensic accounting in fraud detection and prevention. Specifically, a one-unit increase in the effectiveness of whistle-blowing is associated with a 54.2% improvement of forensic accounting performance, particularly in the application of internal controls, auditor independence, and mechanisms of corporate governance. This underpins the instrumental character of whistle-blower systems as a motivator towards fraud detection and ethical accountability in Nigerian banks. This represents 42.5% of forensic accounting effectiveness variability being explained by whistle-blowing activity. This is a moderate explanatory power but also shows that there are other variables (such as regulatory environment, management commitment, and technology tools) which also have an equally important effect on forensic outcomes. After adjusting for the model's predictors' number, 40.2% of variance remains explained, indicating a consistent and reliable model. This is a witness to the robustness of the relationship between whistle-blowing and forensic practice. The value falls into an appropriate range (1.5-2.5), indicating that autocorrelation is not problematic with the model's residuals. This is an indication of validity for the regression estimates. The fact that AIC and Hannan-Quinn are negative reflects that the model is properly balanced between explanatory power and simplicity. The fact that log-likelihood is high reflects that the model explains the data very well, adding to the robustness of the relationships found. Since whistle-blowing is highly correlated with forensic accounting performance, companies need to institutionalize safe and confidential whistle-blower programs. This allowed for early identification of fraud, reduce financial losses, and ensure an open financial culture, since whistle-blowing is beneficial to internal controls and auditor independence, regulatory agencies and board committees should include forensic reporting and whistle-blower protections in corporate governance codes to prevent financial misconduct. The report highlights the requirement of skilled forensic experts to deliver actionable investigations from reports submitted by whistle-blowers. Training and continuous professional development are imperative with the statistical information, policy makers need to revisit current legislation and enforcement mechanisms of whistle-blower protection in Nigeria. Confidentiality and protection to the whistle-blowers will establish trust in the system and improve reporting levels.
Table 1: Relationship between Forensic Accounting and Whistle-blowers for Identifying Irregularities in the
Nigerian Banking Industry
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Variable |
Coefficient |
Std. Error |
t-Statistic |
P-value |
|
C |
0.545209 |
0.360201 |
1.513624 |
0.1344 |
|
Internal_Control |
0.326395 |
0.117151 |
2.786099 |
0.0038 |
|
Whistle_Blowing |
0.321781 |
0.091005 |
3.535846 |
0.0007 |
|
Auditor_Indep |
0.170325 |
0.118769 |
1.434089 |
0.1558 |
|
Corporate_Gov |
0.424847 |
0.081063 |
1.132115 |
0.0020 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
R-squared |
0.425614 |
Mean dependent var |
3.185065 |
|
|
Adjusted
R-squared |
0.402010 |
S.D. dependent var |
0.290764 |
|
|
S.E.
of regression |
0.224847 |
Akaike info criterion |
-0.096239 |
|
|
Sum
squared resid |
3.690614 |
Schwarz criterion |
0.025517 |
|
|
Log
likelihood |
7.705220 |
Hannan-Quinn criter. |
-0.047538 |
|
|
F-statistic |
18.03078 |
Durbin-Watson stat |
1.661854 |
|
|
Prob(F-statistic) |
0.000000 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Source: Authors’
Computation (2024)
The Heteroskedasticity robust standard error estimates the variance ratio for 1.164 tells that magnitude of bank fraud is considerable, and even managers and operational staff commit fraud up to the level of their position. 1.178 for internal control the high frequency of bank failures has been considerable worry recently over the legitimacy of the conventional auditing procedure in the Nigerian banking sector, and corporate governance with a variance ratio of 1.252 that quick action is needed by given the severity of the banks' harm in Nigeria. The maximum joint test value 1.398 with P-value 0.412 indicates that bank fraud has been so prevalent and has resulted in bank collapses, that there has been doubt about the integrity of the standard audit procedure and whistleblowing as reporting of wrongdoing within an organization to internal and external parties to (Sarbanes-Oxley Act, 2002) has attracted legislative attention in the Western World. Auditor independent appears to be a magic bullet that will help to combat fraud and show the preventive role of conventional auditing to become effective and build integrity attributes for an auditor.
Table 2: Cumulated Forensic
Accounting and Whistle-Blowing Martingale |
||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Joint Tests |
Value |
Df |
P-value |
|
|
Max
|z| (at period 2)* |
1.397595 |
77 |
0.4120 |
|
|
Individual
Tests |
|
|
|
|
|
Variable |
Var.
Ratio |
Std.
Error |
z-Statistic |
Probability |
|
Whistle_B. |
1.164725 |
0.117863 |
1.397595 |
0.1622 |
|
Interanl_Co. |
1.178291 |
0.174615 |
1.021050 |
0.3072 |
|
Corpo_Gov. |
1.252112 |
0.217376 |
1.159793 |
0.2461 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
*Probability
approximation using studentized maximum modulus with parameter value 3 and
infinite degrees of freedom. Test Details (Mean = 3.18506493506) |
||||
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Period |
Variance |
Var.
Ratio |
Obs. |
|
|
Whistle_B. |
0.08454 |
-- |
77 |
|
|
Interanl_Co. |
0.09847 |
1.16473 |
76 |
|
|
Corpo_Gov. |
0.09962 |
1.17829 |
75 |
|
|
Auditor_Indep |
0.10586 |
1.25211 |
74 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Source: Authors’
Computation (2024)
Discussion of
Findings
Based on the findings from this study, it clearly stated
that the relationship between forensic
accounting and whistle-blowing fraud investigation: an investigative tool for
identifying irregularities in the Nigerian banking industry has a significant
relationship at a 5% level of significance. Meanwhile, forensic accounting,
internal control, and corporate governance have a significant influence on
whistle-blowing fraud investigations in the Nigerian banking industry. Whereas,
auditor independence has an insignificant relationship with whistle-blowing
fraud investigations. The findings from this study align with the findings of
Ozili (2020) who examined forensic
accounting theory as an explanation of why and how the choice of methods and
techniques used to detect creative accounting or fraudulent manipulations in
financial reporting, and the outcome of using such methods or techniques,
depends on the accounting and non-accounting decisions taken into consideration
by the forensic accountant or investigator. His findings and contribution to
accounting theory and forensic science are useful to the problem-solving
process in the global fight against financial crime. The finding contradicted
the outcome of Apalowowa et al. (2023) whose findings revealed that internal
audit technique, accountability technique, and transparency technique have
statistically significant influence on fraud prevention and detection.
Conclusion and
Recommendations
The study concluded that
establishment of legal protections and offer incentives such as financial
rewards, confidentiality to motivate whistle-blowers to disclose unethical or
fraudulent activities without the risk of retaliation. Financial institutions
in Nigeria needs to establish institutional support for forensic accounting
units require collaboration at the management level with forensic auditors and
assure the incorporation of forensic accounting tasks into fundamental banking
processes, supported by financial and infrastructural resources. The study
recommended that deposit money banks (DMBs) should implement sophisticated
technologies for fraud detection utilise artificial intelligence and machine
learning technologies to improve forensic accounting's ability to promptly and
effectively detect intricate fraud schemes; and allocate resources for the
ongoing education of financial staff and forensic specialists in contemporary
fraud detection methodologies, prioritising digital forensic instruments and
ethical principles.
Implication
Improving whistle-blowing
frameworks with forensic accounting performance, deposit money banks need to
institutionalize safe and confidential whistle-blower programs. This would
allow for early identification of fraud, reduce financial losses, and ensure an open financial
culture.
Regarding Policy
i.
Formulate and implement stringent
whistleblower protection laws, encompassing anti-retaliation provisions and
secure reporting mechanisms.
ii. Establish policy frameworks that require the incorporation of forensic
units and technology in banking regulatory systems.
Practice
i.
Educate bank personnel on forensic
instruments and fraud signs to facilitate early identification.
ii. Establish internal reporting frameworks and assurance processes that
promote ethical behaviour and financial transparency.
REFERENCES
1.
Abdullahi, H. A., & Adamu, M. B. (2022). Whistleblowing
policy and corruption in Niger state: A case study of the transportation
sector. Journal of Transportation
Planning and Technology, 22(4), 456-472.
2.
Adamu, A. A., & Bala, S. M. (2020). Whistleblowing
policy and corruption in Niger state: A case study of the banking sector. Journal of Financial Regulation and
Compliance, 29(3), 312-329.
3.
Adebiyi, O. O. (2023). Exploring the impact of predictive
analytics on accounting and auditing expertise: A regression analysis of
LinkedIn survey data. Available at SSRN 4626506.
4.
Adeleke, O. K., Segun, I. B., & Olaoye, A. I. C. (2019).
Impact of internal control on fraud prevention in deposit money banks in
Nigeria. Nigerian Studies in Economics and Management Sciences, 2(1),
42-51.
5.
Afriyie, S. O., Akomeah, M. O., Amoakohene, G., Ampimah, B.
C., Ocloo, C. E., & Kyei, M. O. (2023). Forensic accounting: A novel
paradigm and relevant knowledge in fraud detection and prevention. International Journal of Public
Administration, 46(9), 615- 624.
6.
Al Shbeil, S., Alshurafat, H., Taha, N., & Al Shbail, M.
O. (2022). What do we know about forensic accounting? A literature review. From
the internet of things to the internet of ideas: The role of artificial
intelligence: Proceedings of EAMMIS,
629-636.
7.
Alharasis, E. E., Haddad, H., Alhadab, M., Shehadeh, M.,
& Hasan, E. F. (2023). Integrating forensic accounting in education and
practices to detect and prevent fraud and misstatement: case study of Jordanian
public sector. Journal of Financial
Reporting and Accounting. DOI 10.1108/JFRA-04-2023-0177.
8.
Alshurafat, H., Alaqrabawi, M., & Al Shbail, M. O.
(2023a). Developing learning objectives for forensic accounting using bloom’s
taxonomy. Accounting Education, 1-17.
9. Apalowowa,
O. D. (2025).
White-collar fraud and whistle-blowing investigations: The role of forensic
auditors in Nigeria. BOHR International Journal of Advances in Management
Research, 4(1), 1-9. DOI: 10.54646/bijamr.2025.40. www.bohrpub.com
10. Apalowowa,
O. D., Alo, O. A., & Ale, O. T. (2023a). Forensic accounting a procedure
for fraud examinations, prevention, and detection of fraudulent activities in
the selected state pension board in the South West, Nigeria. International Journal of Novel Research and
Development, 8(5), i633-i644.
11. Apalowowa,
O. D., Olofintuyi, A. T., Apeko, T. E., & Falusi, I. E. (2023b). Audit
quality control and financial performance of deposit money banks in Ekiti
State, Nigeria. International Journal of
Innovative Science and Research Technology, 8(4), 1372-1378.
12. Apalowowa,
O. D., Omosebi, A., & Akinsete, T. R. (2025). The preventive role of
forensic auditor in white-collar fraud in the Nigerian universities. Global
Scientific Journals, 13(1), 1643-1653.
13. Audu, M.
A., & Garba, H. S. (2021). The effectiveness of whistleblowing policy in
reducing corruption in Niger state: A case study of the wildlife conservation
sector. Journal of Wildlife Management,
16(3), 234-250.
14. Chidi, O.
F., Onwuzuligbo, L. T., ochukwu I. T., Ukamaka, A. (2024). Internal control
system and operational efficiency of supermarkets in Anambra State, Nigeria. Journal of Public Administration, Policy and
Governance Research (JPAPGR), 2(1), 107-120. Available online at
https://jpapgr.com/index.php/research. ISSN:2787-0464. Covered in google
scholar.
15. Choi, J.
N., & Kim, S. (2020). The role of trustworthiness and perceived importance
of confidentiality in encouraging whistleblowing. Journal of Business Ethics, 164(3), 471-489.
16. Daraojimba,
R. E., Farayola, O. A., Olatoye, F. O., Mhlongo, N., & Oke, T. T. (2023).
Forensic accounting in the digital age: a US perspective: scrutinizing methods
and challenges in digital financial fraud prevention. Finance & Accounting Research Journal, 5(11), 342- 360.
17. Dave, N.,
& Patel, D. (2023). Forensic accounting in India: an exploration of
education, practice, and career opportunities. Sachetas, 2(2), 15-22.
18. Efiong, E.
J. (2012). Forensic accounting education: an exploration of level of awareness
in developing economies-Nigeria as a case study. International Journal of Business and Management, 7(4), 26-34.
19. Eiya, O.,
& Otalor, J. I. (2013). Forensic accounting as a tool for fighting
financial crime in Nigeria. Research
Journal of Finance and Accounting, 4(6), 18-25.
20. Felix, U.
O. (2022). Evidence collecting processes and fraud examination: the role of an
expert forensic accountant. Asian Basic
and Applied Research Journal, 394-420.
21. Micelli,
P., & Near, P. (1985). Organisational dissidence: the case of
whistleblowing. Journal of Business
Ethics, 1(4), 20-36.
22. Odeyemi,
O., Ibeh, C. V., Mhlongo, N. Z., Asuzu, O. F., Olatoye, O. F., & Awonuga,
K. F. (2024). Forensic accounting and fraud detection: a review of techniques
in the digital age. Finance &
Accounting Research Journal, 6(2), 202-214. DOI: 10.51594/farj.v6i2.788.
23. Ogbu, S. U.
(2017). Whistle blowing policy as a mechanism for energizing the war against
corruption in Nigeria. International
Journal of International Relations, Media and Mass Communication Studies, 3(4),
26-42.
24. Okonta, C.
N., & Nnamdi, C. A. (2025). Forensic investigation and fraud detection in
Nigeria: Leveraging on Artificial Intelligence. Review of Ethics in
Sustainable Finance and Accounting, 1(1), 31-38.
25. Okwuokei,
E. (2024). Whistle blowing policy in combating corruption in Nigeria: Need for
enabling laws. International Review of
Law and Jurisprudence (IRLJ), 6(1), 145-149.
26. Oladejo, M.
T., & Jack, L. (2020). Fraud prevention and detection in a block-chain
technology environment: challenges posed to forensic accountants. International Journal of Economics and
Accounting, 9(4), 315-335.
27. Olutimehin,
D. O., Ofodile, O. C., Ugochukwu, C. E., & Nwankwo, E. E. (2024). Corporate
governance and stakeholder engagement in Nigerian enterprises: A review of
current practices and future directions. World
Journal of Advanced Research and Reviews, 21(03), 736-742.
28. Omonyemen,
I. S., Josiah, M., & Godwin, O. O. (2017). Internal control as the basis
for prevention, detection and eradication of frauds in banks in Nigeria. International Journal of Economics, Commerce
and Management, 5(9), 61-88.
29. Oyebade, F.
O. (2016). Whistle-blowing as a panacea for fighting corruption in Nigeria.
Being Paper Presented at a Public Lecture Organized by Ibadan and District
Society of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Nigeria (ICAN).
30. Petra, S.,
& Spieler, A. C. (2020). Accounting scandals: Enron, Worldcom, and global
crossing corporate fraud exposed. Emerald Publishing Limited.
31. Romero-Carazas,
R., Espíritu-Martínez, A. P., Aguilar-Cuevas, M. M., Usuriaga-Palacios, M. N.,
Luis Alberto, A., Espinoza-Véliz, M. Z., Espinoza-Egoavil, M. J., &
Gutiérrez-Monzón, S. G. (2024). Forensic auditing and the use of artificial
intelligence: A bibliometric analysis and systematic review in Scopus between
2000 and 2024. Heritage and Sustainable
Development, 6(2), 415-428.
32. Shehu, T.
S. (2025).
Internal control system and fraud mitigation: A case of selected SMEs in
Nigeria. Asian Journal of Advanced Research and Reports, 19(4),
301-315.
33. Stephen, M.
M., Jugu, Y. G., & Addi, T. S. (2025). Investigating the effectiveness of
forensic auditing in fraud detection and prevention in government
organisations: the extent of forensic auditing practices in the Nigerian public
sector. International Journal of African Development and Sustainable
Research,
34. Timothy,
M., & Phiri, J. (2020). The impact of integrated financial management
information systems on procurement process in public sector in developing
countries. A Case of Zambia. Open Journal
of Business and Management, 8, 983-996.
35. Usman, H.
A., & Bala, M. Y. (2021). The impact of whistleblowing policy on corruption
in Niger state: A case study of the oil and gas sector. Journal of Energy Policy, 28(3), 289-305.
36. Vutumu, A.,
Oshota, S. O., & Akinteye, A. S. (2025). Forensic accounting, internal
control impact on Nigerian public sector fraud prevention: A Descriptive
Analysis. Open Journal of Business and Management, 13(2),
781-808.
37. Wokeh, P.
I. (2020). Effect of internal control system on the financial performance of
listed deposit money banks in Nigeria. Innovative
Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, 7(2), 108-115.
38. Yahaya, M.,
Timothy, N., & Dennis, A. I. (2024). Effect of whistleblowing policy on
corruption in Niger state, Nigeria (2015-2019). Journal of Political Discourse, 2(1), 33-44.
39. Yahaya, U.
M., & Musa, A. S. (2021). Whistleblowing policy and corruption in Niger
state: A case study of the renewable energy sector. Journal of Renewable Energy Policy, 36(1), 89-105
0 Comments